October 1, 2026
In 2020, The Post and Courier reported that State Rep. Russell Fry said, "The counties have been operating under the wrong border for decades," describing a mapping error that had gone uncorrected through generations of tax bills, school assignments and election ballots along the southern edge of Murrells Inlet.
The remark wasn't hyperbole. In 2018, officials at the South Carolina Revenue and Fiscal Affairs Office discovered that a strip of land roughly two and a half miles long, running near where U.S. 17 meets Kings Highway, had been treated as Horry County property for as long as anyone could remember. It was actually inside Georgetown County. At least 199 parcels, including homes, businesses and vacant lots, sat on the wrong side of a line drawn in state code back in 1992.
That discovery matters to anyone buying here today for a reason that has nothing to do with 2018. Murrells Inlet's ZIP code, 29576, still straddles the Horry and Georgetown county line, and it does today, not just in the parcels involved in the 2018 discovery. Two houses a few blocks apart can sit in different counties entirely, with different tax assessors, different school districts, different fire coverage rules and different postures on short-term rentals. A listing that says "Murrells Inlet" tells you the marsh is nearby. It does not tell you which county is billing you for it.
The Post and Courier identifies the Georgetown County side of Murrells Inlet and Garden City as Tax District 41, part of a larger system Georgetown uses across the Waccamaw Neck, the stretch of coastline running from the Horry County line down through Pawleys Island to the Waccamaw River bridges at Georgetown. The Horry County side of Murrells Inlet, meanwhile, falls under Horry's own assessor, treasurer and school system entirely.
That 2018 discovery exposed just how easily the line gets blurred in practice. For decades, roughly 200 parcels near the county boundary had been assessed, taxed and represented as Horry County property, even though the legal line put them in Georgetown. Residents in the affected strip packed the Murrells Inlet Community Center to hear State Rep. Lee Hewitt, Fry and State Sen. Stephen Goldfinch explain what happened and what came next: a special referendum, held within the November 2020 general election, that let roughly 250 registered voters in that specific strip decide for themselves whether to formally join Horry County or Georgetown County. At community meetings before the vote, when Fry asked the room for a show of hands on staying in Horry, nearly every hand went up.
The lesson isn't that a handful of streets changed hands. It's that the boundary between these two counties has never been a formality here. It has been contested, corrected and voted on within living memory, and it still runs through the neighborhood today, actively shaping which government office sends your tax notice.
| Horry County side | Georgetown County side | |
|---|---|---|
| Property tax administration | Horry County Assessor and Treasurer | Georgetown County Assessor and Treasurer, Tax District 41 |
| School feeder pattern | Seaside Elementary, St. James Intermediate, St. James Middle, St. James High (Horry County Schools) | Waccamaw-area schools operated by Georgetown County School District |
| Fire and rescue | Murrells Inlet-Garden City Fire District (Horry County side) | Murrells Inlet-Garden City Fire District (Georgetown County side) or Midway Fire Rescue, depending on location |
| Short-term rental posture | Subject to Horry County's zoning and permitting framework | The Offer Sheet describes it as a residential use with no special county permit required in most areas |
None of these differences are cosmetic. Property taxes are another factor to consider. A buyer comparing two similarly priced Murrells Inlet homes can end up with two different annual tax bills for reasons that have nothing to do with square footage or lot size and everything to do with which side of an invisible line the parcel sits on.
The clearest evidence that this line is still operationally real showed up in July 2023, when the Murrells Inlet-Garden City Fire District asked voters to approve a millage increase to address what an audit had called significant understaffing. Because the district's coverage area spans both counties, the referendum wasn't one vote. It was two, tallied separately.
Horry County voters in the district approved it 1,513 to 267. Georgetown County voters in the same district approved it 589 to 188. Same fire trucks, same response times, same chief, and still two separate ballot counts. If you own a home in that district, the service you receive doesn't change at all.
For anyone buying with rental income in mind, the county line carries a second layer of consequence. Georgetown County currently treats short-term rentals, those booked for under 30 days, as a type of residential use rather than a special commercial activity, and in most areas it does not require a separate short-term rental permit. That's a meaningfully lighter regulatory touch than what's emerging elsewhere in the state. Proper.insure reports that Lexington County began requiring an annual zoning permit for unincorporated short-term rentals starting January 1, 2025, complete with septic inspection documentation and a parking plan. The City of Beaufort spent nearly ten months in public meetings before its council voted unanimously in April 2026 to adopt density caps, spacing requirements and a three-strike enforcement policy for short-term rentals.
Georgetown County hasn't followed that path, at least not yet. That doesn't mean every Murrells Inlet property on the Georgetown side is rental-ready. It means the county's default posture is more permissive than the direction several other South Carolina coastal jurisdictions are actively moving, which is worth knowing if a long-term rental strategy depends on that posture holding.
The ZIP code won't tell you. The listing photos won't tell you. Even the mailing address can be misleading, since the 2018 discovery proved that decades of official paperwork treated parcels as being in the wrong county entirely. The only reliable way to know is to pull the parcel by its tax map number and confirm it directly against the current Horry County or Georgetown County assessor records, then verify the school assignment against the relevant district's attendance zone rather than assuming based on the neighborhood name.
For anyone deciding between a Murrells Inlet property and something a few miles north or south, that verification step belongs earlier in the process than most buyers put it, right alongside checking the HOA documents and before making assumptions about the tax bill based on a comparable sale that happened to sit on the other side of the line.
Does the Murrells Inlet ZIP code tell me which county a property is in? No. ZIP 29576 covers Murrells Inlet and nearby areas and crosses both Horry and Georgetown counties, so the ZIP code alone doesn't determine your assessor, school district or fire coverage.
Was the 2018 county line error ever fully resolved? State lawmakers passed enabling legislation to hold a special referendum for the roughly 250 affected voters in November 2020, giving residents in that specific strip a direct say in which county they'd formally join. The broader Horry-Georgetown boundary along the rest of Murrells Inlet was not part of that vote and continues to run through the area as it always has.
If a property is on the Georgetown County side, does that guarantee I can operate a short-term rental? Not automatically. Georgetown County’s general approach is permissive, but confirm the requirements for the specific property before relying on rental income.
If you're comparing Murrells Inlet against another stretch of the Grand Strand and want to know which county, tax district and school zone a specific property actually falls in before you write an offer, Lindsay Jones can pull that parcel history for you and walk through what it means for your bottom line.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Lindsay is dedicated to helping you find your dream home and assisting with any selling needs you may have. She values the trust clients place in her and works tirelessly on their behalf to offer attention to detail for each transaction. Contact her today so he can guide you through the buying and selling process.